Apple Cinnamon Streusel Pie – Batch Bakehouse
Caramel Apple Walnut – Carl’s Cakes/Market Street Diner
Buttermilk Pie – Forequarter
Fat Elvis Pie – Gail Ambrosius
Upside Down Apple Pie – Graze
Maple Custard Pie – Heritage Tavern
Sweet Potato Pecan – Hubbard Ave. Diner
Cheddar Apple Pies – Looking Glass Bakery
Apple Tarte Tatin – Madison Sourdough Co.
Harvest Apple – Norske Nook
Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie – Pickle Jar
Door County Cherry Pie – Willy Street Co-op
Local Pumpkin Pie – Willy Street Co-op
Lamb Bureka – Banzo
Sausage and Roasted Potato Leek Quiche – Beans ‘n Cream Coffeehouse
Harvest Vegetable Quiche – Clasen’s European Bakery
New School Quiche Lorraine – Goodman Community Center Preservation Kitchen
Potato Leek with Parmesan – Honey Bee Bakery
Cheesy Quiche Pies – Landmark Creamery Provisions
Mushroom and Brocolli Quiche – Marigold Kitchen
Spinach Calzones (vegan) – Nature’s Bakery Cooperative
Shiittake Mushroom, Onion and Swiss Quiche – Short Stack Eatery
The Rueben – Vintage Brewing Co.
How do the timed seatings work?
We sell tickets for four timed seatings to assure shorter lines and plenty of seats. You may purchase a ticket for 9:30-10:30am, 10:30-11:30am, 11:30am-12:30pm, or 12:30-1:30pm. Walkups welcome if slots are not sold out.
We will have a good selection (3-4 savory pies and 3-4 sweet pies) available at each of the seatings.
How much to tickets cost?
Advance tickets are $18 per person. Tickets may be purchased online. If time slots are not sold out, tickets will be available at the door on the day of the event for $20.
We do not sell reduced price children’s tickets. But since a meal consists of two slices of pie and a salad and drink, you can choose to share it with your children any way you like. We will sell “extra slice” tickets at the door for ticketholders who feel two slices aren’t quite enough. (Extra slice tickets will be $5)
There will be vegetarian pie options available throughout the day. We’ll note when sweet pies are made with lard in the crusts. Unfortunately, we cannot guarantee options for vegan, gluten-free, or other dietary restrictions.